
Rashad Tucker anyone?
Xztatik, you have got to be joking. Do you think the Adelaide 36ers are the Salvation Army Op Shop taking on every other team's hand me downs. I wouldn't swap him for Chappell as the world is full of more suitable replacements if we need one. Plus the comment on looking back at how he was with Perth, that is a problem that Adelaide has with other players, resting on their previous abilities.

Tucker is not a team player.
I think Cairns will hang on to him, if any of their guns have an off night or if they get into a slump mid game, they can throw tucker and his one man offense in there to try to ignite something.
I don't think he is an improvement on Chappell, just brings different things to the table.
Phil needs to stop being afraid of failure, it is past that! Get out there find a young player with passion for the game, take a risk on someone. Perhaps he's too worried about finding someone to fit the team? The team is struggling maybe its time the team adjusted to a quality import?

I wouldn't take either of them. I'd like to see us go with a new, young and exciting import. I think that will create some more interest among the fans and while there is the possibility of that import being a dud, you can't do much worse than what we have at the moment. Tucker is really not offering much for Cairns either, I don't see how it would be much of an upgrade.
